The Institute of Chartered Accountants
of India (ICAI) may in the coming days
decide to adopt International Financial
Reporting Standards (IFRS) in toto and
shed its current role as an independent
standard setter. It has now set up an 11-
member task force to examine various
issues involved on full convergence and
formulate a concept paper in this regard.
Pages
▼
Wednesday, November 15, 2006
PRICING CODE FOR FOREIGN EXCHANGE DERIVATIVES
The Fixed Income Money Market
and Derivatives Association of India
(FIMMDA), a body of market players,
has issued a code that advises banks
against entering into transactions at rates
or reference levels that differ materially
from market levels.
- The code has called for a process that ensures pricing at market levels, thereby preventing concealment of profit or loss by dealers.
- The code has barred banks from transactions like interest rate swaps
The RBI recently asked select foreign
banks active in the derivatives market
to provide information on derivative
structures sold by them following many
complaints.
Editorial Note :
As per leading experts the corporates
are advise to hedge their foreign
currency risk by plane vanilla
derivative products. The series/
combination of vanilla products
could also be considered. This
will facilitate:
- Competitive pricing as simple products are offered at very reasonable cost
- Unwinding of all or certain legs of the hedging transactions will be very easy once the corporate see that the market has improved and hedging risk has reduced.
NO LOCK-IN OF SALE PROCEEDS
Non Resident Indians (NRIs) can
now remit up to $ 1 million per year abroad
immediately after they sell immovable
property.
So far, NRIs and Persons of Indian origin
(PIOs) had to lock in their sale proceeds
for a certain period in their Non-Resident
Ordinary (NRO) accounts. Now, the RBI
has done away with the lock-in period. However, the annual ceiling on total
remittance out of NRO accounts will
remain at $ 1 million.
NO ‘SAFETY NET’ TO PUBLIC ISSUES
The Reserve Bank of India has told
banks and their subsidiaries not to offer
“safety net” facilities to public issues.
There is also no income for the banks to
corrospond with the risk of loss built into
these schemes as the investor will take
recourse to the safety net only when the
market value of the share falls below the
pre determined price.
SELF-REGULATORY BODY FOR BOURSES TO BE SET UP
SEBI is planning to set up Self
Regulatory Organisations (SROs) soon
for surveillance of the capital market. The
SROs will constitute to represent capital
market participants with adequate (20%
to 30%) SEBI nominees to represent
independent professionals, investors and
SEBI officials. These SROs will exercise
all day-to-day supervisions, surveillance,
inspection and investigation on market
participants. According to a SEBI
official, the idea is to rope in independent
professionals such as practicing chartered
accountants, lawyers and financial experts
to do this job. The proposed separate
entity would be in a position to hire
professionals on assignment-basis.
Instead of making disclosure to the BSE,
NSE and SEBI, the regulator is working
on uniform e-filing of disclosure details.
This way, while compliance is not diluted,
its cost will be minimised.
SEBI TIGHTENS NORMS FOR VC FUNDS’ IPO
Sebi has tightened norms
for offloading shares held by
Venture Capital Funds (VCFs)
and investors through an IPO to
make the Indian primary market
more efficient and transparent.
The revised Disclosure and
Investor Protection guidelines
restricted the benefit of ‘No lockin’
on the pre-issue of shares of
an unlisted company, launching
the initial public offering on
shares held by Venture Capital
Funds and Foreign Venture
Capital Investors (FVCIs). This
no lock-in facility will hereafter be available to the shares held by VCFs
and FVCIs, which are registered for at
least one year.
CDSL TO ISSUE IIN FOR MF INVESTORS
Central Depository Services
(India) Ltd. (CDSL) has
been appointed as the issuing
authority of “Investors
Identification Number (IIN)”
previously known as Client
Identification Number. The
deadline to issue IIN, has been
extended to January 1,2007.
Editorial Note :
A demat account number of investor or PAN number could be considered as enough for MF investors. AMFI should work out data sharing with NSDL and CDSL without requiring investors to incur cost and effort to obtain another identification.
Editorial Note :
A demat account number of investor or PAN number could be considered as enough for MF investors. AMFI should work out data sharing with NSDL and CDSL without requiring investors to incur cost and effort to obtain another identification.
FMC CRACKS THE WHIP AT TRADERS FOR NONCOMPLIANCE OF DELIVERY NORMS
Forward Markets Commission
(FMC) will levy stiff penalties
for traders who don’t comply
with delivery obligations under
mandatory delivery contracts.
NYMEX TO LAUNCH ELECTRONIC CONTRACTS
The New York Mercantile Exchange
(Nymex), the world’s biggest energy
market-place, will introduce electronic
contracts to compete with the London
Metals Exchange (LME) if a buyout of
trading rights is approved by members.
SMALL FIRMS COULD BE HIT UNDER NEW INSURANCE REGIME
Small and medium companies are
likely to be the worst affected in a
regime where there are no controls
on premium charged on general
insurance risks.
The proposed lifting of controls on
premium rates is expected to bring to an end
the prevalent practice of cross-subsidising
tariff-free group health insurance and
marine risks against profitable portfolios
like fire and engineering covers, premium
rates for which are tariff based. General
insurance would move to estimating
premium rates based on assessment of
risks on a standalone basis from a client
portfolio basis.
IRDA CODE OF CONDUCT FOR BROKERS, INSURERS
To ensure healthy competition in
the general insurance sector after it is
de-tariffed, the Insurance Regulatory
and Development Authority (IRDA) has
set out a code of conduct for brokers
and insurers. These, they will have to
mandatorily adhere to, especially for
large accounts. Any deviation will
require Irda’s prior approval.
RELIEF TO INSURERS ON PAYMENT OF INTEREST
The Supreme Court has ruled that
the insurance companies are liable to
pay the interest as damages on delayed
payment of the insured amount from
the date of awarding of the compensation.
Such damages shall not be claimed
from the date of claim or correspondence
in this regard started between the
parties concerned.
IRDA TO MONITOR SOLVENCY MARGIN
Post-detariffing from Jan 07, Irda
would monitor solvency of general
insurance companies on a monthly
basis. The accounting as well as actuary
professional’s role is going to be more
important.
NEW IRDA NORMS FOR NONLIFE COVERS
With the free pricing (detariffed) era for
general insurance industry nearing, the
Insurance Regulatory and Development
Authority (IRDA) has announced new
guidelines for ‘file and use’ requirements
for general insurance products.
Keeping in mind the interests of
policyholders, it has retained the authority
of suspending the sale of products at
anytime if they appear inappropriate and
unfair in terms of rates and terms and
conditions.
IRDA has made it clear that the insurers
would be required to justify the rates
and terms and conditions of insurance
products offered and said it would not
accept a mere statement that the risk is
rated ‘on merits’.
NO SERVICE TAX ON FEES FOR CAMPUS INTERVIEWS: CBEC
The Central Board of Excise and
Customs (CBEC) recently clarified that
educational institutes like IITs and IIMs
were not liable to pay service tax under
the category of “manpower recruitment or
supply service” on the fees charged from
prospective employers like corporates,
who come to these institutes for recruiting
candidates through campus interviews.
These institutes were not liable to pay
service tax prior to May 1, 2006 under
the category of ‘manpower recruitment or
supply service’ as during this period only
commercial concerns were to be taxed.
As regards the period after May 2006,
decision should be taken after taking into
account all material facts on case to case
basis.
INSURERS MAY HAVE TO ABSORB EXTRA SERVICE TAX
General Insurance companies
will have to reckon paying
extra service tax on premium
if the rate is hiked mid-way
during the tenure of a policy.
Policyholders, in turn, could
feel the pinch if the extra cost
is passed on to them. In an
order passed recently on Bajaj
Allianz General Insurance, the
Commissioner (Excise) struck
down the company’s contention
that it does not have to pay extra
service tax, consequent to the
hike in service tax rate. The case
relates to Sept 04, when the rate
was revised from 8% to 10%.
NOTICES ISSUED TO COs CLAIMING ABATEMENT ON PAYMENTS TO GTA
Trouble seems to be brewing
up for companies availing
services of Goods Transport
Agencies (GTAs). The service
tax department has issued
show cause notices to them for
claiming abatement for service
tax on payments made to GTA.
The issue of claiming abatement
for service tax on payments
made to GTA has been hanging
fire for quite some time. While
the Central Board of Excise and
Customs had said the companies
could claim an abatement of
75%, the Comptroller and
Auditor General (CAG) had
raised objections to it. In wake
of CAG objection and no
clarification on the issue, the
field formations have raised
demands and show cause notices
have been issued.
Editorial Note :
The show cause notices are illegal. The abatement circular is binding on the Government.
Editorial Note :
The show cause notices are illegal. The abatement circular is binding on the Government.
SUMMONS TO SHIPPING FIRMS ON SERVICE TAX PAYMENT
The Directorate General of Central Excise
Intelligence (DGCEI), as a part of its
inquiry into evasion of service tax, has
issued summons to all domestic shipping
companies, asking them to submit
information on services availed abroad
and payments made in foreign exchange
retrospectively since August 16, 2002.
BANKING SERVICES TO SEZ UNITS OUT OF TAX NET
Banking services offered to units set up
in Special Economic Zones (SEZs) have
been exempted from paying service tax.
The clarification has been issued by the
Central Board of Excise and Customs
(CBEC) in response to a query from the
Indian Banks’ Association (IBA).
NEW FORMAT FOR ER-1 & ER-3 EXCISE RETURNS ISSUED
Following the functioning of Large Tax
Payers Unit (LTUs) from October 1, the
department of revenue has issued a revised
format for ER-1 and ER-3 returns for all
Central Excise assessees on October 12,
2006. The ER1 and ER3 return forms are
applicable for all assessees, including
large taxpayers. In the new format, the
department has included new tables to get
information on inter unit movements of
intermediate goods of large taxpayers who
have opted for LTU. Similarly, the excess
CENVAT Credit transfer to deficient
transfer are also sought in the new form.
A large taxpayer has the option to transfer
any excess CENVAT credit (of Central
Excise Duty or Service Tax) accumulated
in one manufacturing unit or service
providing unit to any other unit under
cover of a transfer voucher under rule
12A(4) of the CENVAT Credit Rules,
2004. Self-adjustment of excess duty paid
through CENVAT credit account must be
reported to the excise office. Other details
such as credit taken on imported inputs,
and credit taken on imported capital
goods, are also being sought from all
central excise assessees.
CBEC MULLS SERVICE TAX RELIEF FOR ONSCREEN SERVICES OF BOURSES
Stock and commodity exchanges could
be on their way to getting some relief on
service tax. The Central Board of Excise
and Customs (CBEC) is examining
whether onscreen services provided by
stock and commodity exchanges to their
members are taxable or not.
INCOME TAX DECISIONS
Lower rate of tax under DTAA
Hon’ble Madras High Court in the matter of CIT vs. Reiter Ingolsteadt Spimereimaschinenbau AG held that benefit of lower tax rate will go to assessee even when the DTA Agreement was informal by exchange of notes only. [285 ITR 199].
Withdrawal of registration u/s 12A of the Income Tax Act Hon’ble Uttaranchal High Court in the matter of Welham Boys’ School Society vs. Central Board of Direct Taxes, held that once registration is granted u/s 12A there is no inherent power to the registering authority to rescind it on the ground that the institution was running for profit. There is no power in the statute available to the registering authority to cancel the registration. Even assuming that it is possible, it cannot be cancelled, unless the original registration was obtained by practicing fraud or forgery. [285 ITR 74 ].
Attachment of bank account in respect of disputed tax by Income tax officials Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the matter of Coco Cola India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Addl. CIT cautioned the revenue to advise its officers strictly to follow the appropriate procedures and take such coercive action in case where it is so required after observing the requirement of law. Where an appeal has been filed, no coercive action can be taken till the time the appeal is over and after such period, consider coercive action, if no application is filed and if filed, deal with the same only on merit after considering the parameter set out by the Court. [285 ITR 419].
Revisional Jurisdiction u/s 263 of the Income Tax Act Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in the matter of CIT Vs. Mangilal Didwania found that once assessing officer made enquiries into various aspects of the case and applied his mind before framing the assessment, there is no jurisdiction for the Commissioner who holds assessment order as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of revenue. [286 ITR 126].
Non-resident NGO’s are liable to pay fringe benefit tax Hon’ble Authority for Advance Ruling (Income Tax) in the matter of Population Council Inc. given a ruling that the applicant of non-resident non-profit making organization, having a regional office in India, which carried on charitable, scientific and educational activities, was liable to pay fringe benefit tax u/s 115WA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, in relation to fringe benefits provided to its employees. [286 ITR 243].
Hon’ble Madras High Court in the matter of CIT vs. Reiter Ingolsteadt Spimereimaschinenbau AG held that benefit of lower tax rate will go to assessee even when the DTA Agreement was informal by exchange of notes only. [285 ITR 199].
Withdrawal of registration u/s 12A of the Income Tax Act Hon’ble Uttaranchal High Court in the matter of Welham Boys’ School Society vs. Central Board of Direct Taxes, held that once registration is granted u/s 12A there is no inherent power to the registering authority to rescind it on the ground that the institution was running for profit. There is no power in the statute available to the registering authority to cancel the registration. Even assuming that it is possible, it cannot be cancelled, unless the original registration was obtained by practicing fraud or forgery. [285 ITR 74 ].
Attachment of bank account in respect of disputed tax by Income tax officials Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the matter of Coco Cola India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Addl. CIT cautioned the revenue to advise its officers strictly to follow the appropriate procedures and take such coercive action in case where it is so required after observing the requirement of law. Where an appeal has been filed, no coercive action can be taken till the time the appeal is over and after such period, consider coercive action, if no application is filed and if filed, deal with the same only on merit after considering the parameter set out by the Court. [285 ITR 419].
Revisional Jurisdiction u/s 263 of the Income Tax Act Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in the matter of CIT Vs. Mangilal Didwania found that once assessing officer made enquiries into various aspects of the case and applied his mind before framing the assessment, there is no jurisdiction for the Commissioner who holds assessment order as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of revenue. [286 ITR 126].
Non-resident NGO’s are liable to pay fringe benefit tax Hon’ble Authority for Advance Ruling (Income Tax) in the matter of Population Council Inc. given a ruling that the applicant of non-resident non-profit making organization, having a regional office in India, which carried on charitable, scientific and educational activities, was liable to pay fringe benefit tax u/s 115WA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, in relation to fringe benefits provided to its employees. [286 ITR 243].
TECHNICAL SNAGS BUG EFILING OF TAX RETURNS
Tax payers across the country have been
facing great difficulties in electronic filing
of tax returns on account of technical
snags in the software developed by the
Income Tax Department. The system is
in the process of regular modification to
correct errors or logic mismatch.
RETURNS DEADLINE FOR CORPORATES EXTENDED
The Government has extended the due
date for corporates to obtain the Tax
Audit Report and furnish the Return of
Income and Fringe Benefits to November
30 from October 31 for the Assessment
year 2006-07.
TAX HOLIDAY FOR DELHI BUDGET HOTELS
The Government is considering granting
infrastructure status to all budget hotels
and convention centers set up in Delhi and
National Capital Region between now and
the 2010 Commonwealth Games. This
will enable them to enjoy a 10-year tax
holiday as in case of other infrastructure
projects such as roads, ports and power.
The move will help to meet an estimated
demand for 1,00,000 hotel rooms in Delhi
and NCR during the Commonwealth
Games and correct the skew that is
currently in favour of luxury and first class
properties.
OBTAINING PAN NOW EASIER FOR NRIs
Obtaining a Permanent Account Number
(PAN) for Indians living abroad, a foreign
citizen, or a company, trust or firm not
having an office in India has become
easier. The Income Tax department has
clarified that it will no longer insist on
details of a “representative assessee”
while accepting PAN applications from
the aforementioned categories.
The tax department has issued a circular
to the two designated PAN service
providers – UTI Technology Services
Ltd. and National Securities Depositories
Ltd. – clarifying on the revised guidelines
for allotment of PAN to these categories.
NEWSPAPERS’ AD PAYMENTS LIABLE TO BE TAXED
The Central Board of Direct
Taxes has informed the Indian
Newspaper Society (INS)
that Tax Deducted at Source
(TDS) is liable to be deducted
by newspapers on payments
made by them to advertising
agencies.
The CBDT has written to the INS
following a clarification sought
by the latter on whether TDS
was deductible on payments
made by them to advertising
agents. The contention of INS
was that such payments are not
in the nature of a commission
but a discount. So no TDS was
liable on such payments.
However, revenue department
officials said the CBDT was of
the view that such payments
were covered by the definition
of the term ‘commission or
brokerage’ given in Section
194H of the Income Tax Act
and hence liable to TDS.
TRADE MARKS OF INDIAN COs TO BE PROTECTED ABROAD
With more and more Indian companies
going global, the government has decided
to protect the trademarks of Indian firms
abroad. India is planning to become
a part of the Madrid International
Protocol (MIP) for trademarks under the
World Intellectual Property Rights
Organisation (WIPO).
The protocol has a 78-country
membership. Indian companies will
be able to get trademark protection
in all these countries by simply
filing one trademark application at
the local or regional trademark office.
If the trademark office of a
designated country does not refuse
protection within a specified period,
the mark is considered as registered.
MIP also allows for recording
subsequent changes and renewal of
trademarks by the same single step
procedure.
CABINET NOD TO IT ACT AMENDMENTS
With an aim to enforcing stricter data
security laws in the wake of data thefts from
BPOs in the country, the Union Cabinet
on Monday approved amendments to the
Information Technology (IT) Act 2000.
The amendments are aimed at preventing
computer misuse like video voyeurism,
identify theft, e-commerce frauds like
phasing, frauds on online auction sites,
sending offensive emails, etc.
OUTSOURCING UNITS CANNOT BE CLUBBED FOR EPF
The Delhi High Court has ruled that
outsourcing units cannot be clubbed with
each other or the company outsourcing
work to them, for the purpose of taking
the benefit of Employees Provident
Fund (EPF). These ancillary units are
independent business entities despite
the fact that they are dependent on an
automobile company or engineering
firm. These units cannot be clubbed with
each other or with main company for
purpose of EPF Act on the ground of
interdependence.
BUILDERS FINALLY GET HEMMED IN BY DEADLINES
The Government has made it
mandatory for developers to adhere to
deadlines on finished housing properties.
Property developers will now have to
refund the entire advance amount with
interest if they fail to deliver flats to
customers in the agreed time-frame.
COACHING CENTRES TOLD NOT TO CHARGE FEES IN ONE GO
As per Delhi State Consumer Disputes
Redressal Commission all training
imparting institutes, educational
centres preparing students for entrance
examinations have been directed not
to charge the fee for the whole duration
of the course in advance by way of
lump sum payment. They are duty bound
to refund fee for balance period to a
student who does not wish to pursue the
course further.
MONEY LAUNDERING ACT TO BE AMENDED
Indian Banks can now look
forward to easy entry into
the US financial market. The
Government has to decided
to move amendments to
the Prevention of Money
Laundering (PML) Act, which
will make it more in sync with
the demands of the US and EU.
The amendments will bring
terrorism financing and Customs
offences under the glare of the
Act. While the International
Financial Action Task Force
(FATF) has also asked for
making insider trading in stock
markets a money laundering
offence, the Government is not
in favour.
STATES FOR UNIFORM STAMP DUTY ON DEBIT INSTRUMENTS
India’s moribund debt market
is set to finally get a leg up
with State Governments
granting an in-principle approval
to rationalize stamp duty on a
host of financial instruments
including debentures and
promissory notes.
Reforms have long been in the
offing in the local debt market
but a major stumbling block has
been the levy of stamp duty. A
sub-group set up by the standing
committee of finance secretaries
on stamp and registration has
decided to recommend uniform
stamp duties on these financial
instruments across all states.
BEST PRACTICE GUIDE ON ESTABLISHING CREDIT BUREAUS BY IFC
The International Finance Corporation
(IFC), the private sector arm of the
World Bank Group, has launched a
new guide explaining how to establish
Credit Bureaus. The guide, entitled
Credit Bureau Knowledge Guide,
is the first publication to prove a
comprehensive overview of the
development of Credit Bureaus.
RBI TIGHTENS REALTY LENDING NORM
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
norms for lending to the real estate
sector are getting stricter. After blocking
funding for purchase of land, the central
bank has further tightened its measures
for checking flow of funds from banks
to the real estate sector. It has asked
banks to ensure that credit disbursed is
used only for “productive construction
activity.” The risk weights of bank’s
exposure to commercial real estate
and home loans above Rs. 20 Lacs has
been raised to 150 bps.
The banks need to monitor diversion of
funds to speculative trading/investments.
TRADING IN CORPORATE BONDS : SEEKS SEPARATE PLATFORM FOR BANKS AND FIs
SEBI’s plan to create a uniform
exchange for trading in corporate bonds is
stuck with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
seeking a separate platform for banks
and Financial Institutions (FIs).
An RBI committee is understood to
have pointed out that banks and FIs
will face settlement problems if they
trade on the platform of the BSE,
chosen by SEBI for on-line trading in
corporate bonds. The committee has
suggested a separate trading system
for banks and FIs.
Participation of brokers is to be tackled.
RBI is not comfortable with the deals
getting routed through brokers and
instead prefers an order matching system
for better transparency.
KYC NORMS EASED FOR SMALL BANK ACCOUNTS
The stringent Know Your Customer
(KYC) norms had forced banks to put
off many small customers or those aspiring
to be part of the banking system. RBI has
now done away with the requirement to
follow the KYC norms for customers in
cases where the outstanding balance is not
more than Rs. 50,000 and the maximum
transaction is not more than Rs. 2 lakh.
In such cases, customers will need
to provide just a photograph and
self-certification of address. However,
as and when the transaction size and
the balance increased beyond the limit,
banks would be required to follow the
normal KYC norms. RBI has also made
life easier for the retired people by
allowing them to operate a joint account
for receiving pension payments. RBI said
that it would allow crediting of the pension
amount to a joint account operated by
pensioner with her / his spouse where
family pension has been authorized.
RBI TELLS STATES NOT TO REGULATE INTEREST RATES CHARGED BY MFIs
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has told
some of the State Governments to refrain
from regulating interest rates charged by
Micro-Finance Institutions (MFIs). The
regulator feels that the various money
lending legislations, which put a cap on
the interest rate charged by an entity (not
banks), should not apply to MFIs.
This comes on the back of a recent
incident in Andhra Pradesh where the
State Government pulled up local MFIs
for competing with the state’s lending
programme .
The RBI is understood to be of the
view that the provisions of the Money
Lending Act should not apply to MFIs
operating in the form of Non-Banking
Financial Companies (NBFCs) and
companies which do not declare dividend
and are registered under Section 25
of the Companies Act. However,
state legislations may continue to govern
MFIs operating as trusts or NGOs.
CLEARANCE TO 44 NEW SEZs
At its meeting on 27th October,
2006 the Board of Approvals
in the Commerce Ministry
gave formal clearances to
24 SEZ proposals and
in-principle nod to 20 others,
entailing an aggregate
investment of Rs. 40,000
crore. That takes the total
applications so far approved to
236 and those with in-principle
clearance to 169.
FIRST PVT. GOLD MINE TO BE OPERATIONAL IN 07
- Ramgad Minerals and Mining Pvt. Ltd., a Mineral Sales Pvt. Ltd. Group firm, has struck gold in Gadag district in Central Karnataka.
- The firm obtained gold reconnaissance permits and prospecting licence in an area covering 10,000 square km in Gadag, four years ago.
CENTRE FINETUNES MCA TO WOO FOREIGN INVESTORS
The government is further fine tuning
the model concession
agreement (MCA) and making
changes in its policy framework
to attract foreign investment
to finance mega infrastructure
projects.
GOVT CALLS MEET ON NRI VARSITIES IN SEZs
In a bid to use Special Economic
Zones (SEZs) to promote
investment in higher education,
the Cabinet Secretariat has
called a meeting of a committee
of secretaries to discuss the
policy for setting up of Non Resident
Indian (NRI)/People of
Indian Origin (PIO) universities
in these zones.
DIN-3 CERTIFICATION – EXCLUSIVELY TO CS – REQUIRING SERIOUS RECONSIDERATION
The Ministry of Company Affairs, Government of India has
recently notified DIN-3 to be mandatory submitted by all
the companies to the Registrar of Companies on or before
7th December, 2006, wherein the companies are required
to inform the DIN (Director Identification Number) of their
Director to Registrar of Companies through MCA-21 Portal,
duly certified by:
- A Company Secretary in full time practice or
- A Company Secretary in employment of the concerned Company
It may be noted that the Chartered Accountants or Company
Secretaries are permitted to certify all the forms under MCA
21 requiring certification so far and this is the first time that
the Chartered Accountants in practice are not recognized by
Ministry of Company Affairs for authenticating DIN-3. As a
matter of principle, this is a serious departure. The Chartered
Accountants have been rendering valuable services to the
corporate sector including incorporation of companies,
company law compliance's, filing of various forms, maintenance
of statutory records, representing before the Hon’ble Company
Law Board and Ministry of Company Affairs for obtaining
various approvals and similar other services. The CA Course
Curriculum and 3- years practical training provide an expert
knowledge to Chartered Accountants to provide valuable
services in the corporate law sector including Company Law,
SEBI Act, Competition Act and various other Economic and
Corporate legislations.
The Chartered Accountants fraternity need to take up with
Ministry of Company Affairs that Chartered Accountants
cannot and should not be distinguished, while providing various
key services to the corporate sector and it may be completely
inappropriate to provide exclusivity to the Company Secretaries
in relation to any professional service related to Company Law.
It may be noted that 4 members of the Central Council out
of 12 elected members recently resigned few months ago from
the Membership of the Central Council of ICSI in protest
against the Ministry of Company Affairs not providing exclusivity to Company Secretaries for certifying various forms under
MCA-21. The provision of exclusivity to Company Secretaries
in certifying DIN-3 is being viewed as a result of these pressure
tactics, which is highly unfortunate.
It may be noted that the compliance certification of listing
guidelines including corporate governance were earlier
exclusively reserved by SEBI in favour of Chartered Accountants
and in-spite of several aspects requiring deep knowledge of
financial accounting and financial matters, Company Secretaries
in whole time practice have also been permitted to certify
corporate governance compliance.
The corporate law services provide a very important, challenging
and promising avenue for the profession of Chartered Accountants
and those who are able to have specialized knowledge are able
to command a very good respect, seniority and professional
standing. It may be necessary for the Institute of Chartered
Accountants of India and various Chartered Accountants’
Associations to project Chartered Accountants as highly
competent professionals having holistic knowledge of corporate
law and affairs with an in-depth understanding of financial nitty
gritty to take challenges of complex business dimensions in a
comprehensive approach to derive the best results.
- ICAI may consider prescribing corporate law standards and issuing guidance note on various aspects of Company Law and various other corporate law compliance's, procedures and complex aspects of such laws as may be considered important from time to time.
- A guidance note on MCA21 certification may be issued urgently.
- CA professional bodies may consider publishing advertisements, pamphlets, brochures and similar other publicity materials outlining various important aspects of professional services being provided by Chartered Accountants to the corporate fraternity.
- To publish easy to understand handbook and guides to enable provisioning of complex as well as routine corporate law services by Chartered Accountants to their clients. This may include procedure, forms, compliance and practical tips as well as check-list to enable Chartered Accountants to easily provide various services in a standardized manner.
We need to strengthen our competitive
positions in the corporate law sector
consciously and actively.