• Small Discription For Image - 1.

  • Small Discription For Image - 2.

  • Small Discription For Image - 3.

  • Small Discription For Image - 4.

New Post

Rss

Showing posts with label Editorial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Editorial. Show all posts
Wednesday, March 15, 2017
INDIAN CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS MEETING NEW CHALLENGES

INDIAN CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS MEETING NEW CHALLENGES

The Indian chartered accountant firms have taken a big leap in last 10 years and are facing now one of the most happening and challenging era full of opportunities. The Indian Chartered Accountants
(CA) firms have been witnessing growth of professional accounting in India and have qualitatively handled large number of audits, tax matters and consulting assignments based on their knowledge and expertise in infrastructure and professional competence.
Indian CA firms managed in terms of Indian culture and Ethos are highly ethical and ensure that financial statements once certified or audited by them are free from fraud and error
The Indian CA firms have wide geographical presence in India and overseas and are competing with international CA firms not only for large assignments but also for mid size clients. Indian chartered accounting firms have been following highest level of standards and professional competence and have made significant efforts to improve Brand India.
All major borrowers of corporate sector and banks in India, where frauds were discovered were not subject to audit by an Indian CA firm
The Indian CA firms are also being supported by a large number of corporate professionals, government officials, bankers and highly placed persons due to the effective and efficient professional services being provided by these Indian CA firms. Even a large number of international
collaborators, venture capitalists, foreign investors mandate appointment of Indian firms as auditors and for several other important assignments.
Indian CA firms guarantee and ensure that money and resources are neither wasted nor diverted or siphoned off 
The Indian CA firms have been vigorously working to gain strength to meet challenges and reap new
opportunities. A large number of Indian CA firms have also established themselves at several Indian and International locations and are expanding geographically in size and in view of their commitment towards growth and prosperity of their clients. These firms have also added to their strength, number of their professional partners and other experts.
Once an Indian CA reviews financial statements or accounts, all material or potential frauds and errors are brought to light
The advent of liberalisation and now a concrete visionary action of the new government to bring in
transparency and to eradicate corruption and black money have brought the role of Indian CA firms to centre stage.
The Prime Minister Narendra Modi have called upon the nation to take a pledge to achieve major milestone and targets so as to make significant growth in next 5 years and take India to new heights by 2022, when India will be completing 75 years of independence. There are large number of new opportunities and challenges for Indian Chartered Accountants to shape India's future in the right direction including:To increase tax compliance and educate more and more Indians to be fully compliant with the tax laws.


  • To implement biggest tax reforms "Goods and Service tax" in a fair and effective manner by their clients, businesses and all the stakeholders.
  • Demonetisation has also brought several enquires, investigations, surveys, searches and raids. It is important to grant real justice in all these cases. Professionalism of highest order of Indian CA firm will be of biggest help and support to distinguish genuine cases.
  • Benami Property prohibition law is being administered by the tax department which will severely impact spurious transactions. Already hundred of show cause notices and confiscation of properties have been initiated. 
  • Capital market is getting activated and is on unprecedented growth path. Merchant banking, brokerages, mutual funds, private equity funds, infrastructure fund & all latest financial products, financial structuring, corporate structuring will need CA's for their active professional hand holding support.
  • Banking sector suffering from large scale nonperforming assets have brought a new challenge to manage the corporate and businesses effectively and efficiently and to bring in financial modes of sustained growth. The financial management, control, discipline and devoted austelity measures by cutting cost and improving performance are real challenging targets to be met by Indian CAs.

Indian CAs have commited to eradicate corruption and unethical practices from the financial system. A Special Action Task Force(SATF) has been constituted to run operation "Black Belt"
The Chartered Accountants also have to work as intellectuals policy makers to evolve new strategies, to maximize with compliance and to keep the requirements of filing and other procedures to the minimum.
Wednesday, February 15, 2017
Residence test for companies- POEM Guidelines

Residence test for companies- POEM Guidelines

Section 6(3) of the Act were amended vide Finance Act, 2015, with effect from 1st April, 2016 to provide that a company is said to be resident in India in any previous year, if- 
It is an Indian company; or
Its place of effective management in that year is in India.
A company shall be said to be engaged in “active business outside India” if the passive income is not more than 50% of its total income; and
  • Less than 50% of its total assets are situated in India; and
  • Less than 50% of total number of employees are situated in India or are resident in India; and
  • The payroll expenses incurred on such employees is less than 50% of its total payroll expenditure.

“Passive income” of a company shall be aggregate of, -
  • Income from the transactions where both the purchase and sale of goods is from / to its associated enterprises; and
  • Income by way of royalty, dividend, capital gains,interest or rental income;

However, any income by way of interest shall not be considered to be passive income in case of a company which is engaged in the business of banking or is a public financial institution, and its activities are regulated as such under the applicable laws of the country of incorporation. “Senior Management” in respect of a company means the person or persons who are generally responsible for developing and formulating key strategies and policies for the company and may include Managing Director/CEO, Director of Finance/CFO, COO, Sales head, Technology or Production head.

The place of effective management in case of a company engaged in active business outside India shall be presumed to be outside India if the majority meetings of the board of directors of the company are held outside India unless the Board of directors of the company are standing aside and not exercising their powers of management.For the purpose of determining whether the company is engaged in active business outside India, the average of the data of the previous year and two years prior to that shall be taken into account. In cases of companies other than those that are engaged in active business outside India:-

  • First stage would be identification or ascertaining the person or persons who actually make the key management and commercial decision for conduct of the company’s business as a whole.
  • Second stage would be determination of place where these decisions are in fact being made.

Some of the guiding principles:-
  • The location where a company’s Board regularly meets and makes decisions.
  • If a board has de facto delegated the authority, place of effective management will ordinarily be the place where these senior managers or the other person make those decisions.
  • The location where the members of the executive committee are based and where that committee develops and formulates the key strategies and policies for mere formal approval
  • The location of a company’s head office.
  • The decisions made by shareholder on matters which are reserved for shareholder decision under the company laws are not relevant for
  • determination of a company’s place of effective management.
  • It may be clarified that day to day routine operational decisions undertaken by junior and middle management shall not be relevant for the purpose of determination of POEM.

If the above factors do not lead to clear identification of POEM then the following secondary factors can be considered:-
  • Place where main and substantial activity of the company is carried out; or
  • Place where the accounting records of the company are kept.

Determination of POEM is to be based on all relevant facts. POEM shall be presumed to be in India if it has been mainly /predominantly in India.
BANKING SECTOR- LOOKING FOR GROWTH CATALYST, STRATEGY , MONITORING NEED

BANKING SECTOR- LOOKING FOR GROWTH CATALYST, STRATEGY , MONITORING NEED

The banking sector has passed through turmoil during last few years of UPA II and the Indiscrete lending without adequate due diligence, non adherence to financial management principles, excessive leveraging, diversion of funds and lust for too fast growth has brought to us now a very serious situation. The growth of banking sector and their sustained existence has become a matter of very serious concern for last 2 years.The banks are now flush with funds due to demonetisation and lack of credit growth and still are not able to lend, in the absence of visionary management, lack of proposals, big hesitation in banking sector to further lend even to good proposals. The fear of CBI and vigilance regarding backdrop of large NPA's are dissuading bankers to take pragmatic decisions inspite of very significant positive structural change and basic policy changes.Supporting a growth scenario, the promoters are not coming forward to take on expansions or diversification, specially in manufacturing sector.The lack of risk capital inflow in the absence of credibility of capital market is another big damper. A major reform strategy is needed in public private partnership to bring out new investment, where the equity support is provided by the Government, Central and State PSU's, banks and investment pulling vehicles. The real sustained growth will come by regular application of basic financial management principles, transparency, ethics and real corporate governance. The government and RBI need to beef up regulatory and monitoring systems and need not micro-manage the affair of banks. The Equity (Risk) Capital needs to be channelized into new and expansive units bringing cost of the funds substantially down. The Gross NPA and Net NPA both are very large. A significant portion, 70% of these asset is locked into large borrowed 5000 crores or more as a group. The regulatory mechanism of RBI and functional control as well as administrative mechanism of individual banks has failed miserably. Even private sector banks have suffered deep NPA losses. The Banking Sector is backbone of Indian economy and for sustained growth of manufacturing, services,
agricultural as well as to achieve Make in India, a vibrant and strong Banking Sector is a must. The role of catalyst is to be played by top financial experts to check out a clear strategy for revival of all borrowing entities by bringing their debt levels to sustainable level. The following suggestions may be considered by Bank
Sector:-
  • Construction of Special Task Force in all banks
  • Purchase of all such assets in a separate pool by bank for further disposal- as a trustee
  • Restructuring of Advances
  • Options to management to pay optionally convertible debenture over 8 years after 2 year moratorium.
  • Separate Bad Bank- may be reconsidered as it may be too difficult by one entity to manage so much.
  • Independent Bank Directors
  • Recapitalization of Small Banks needed for growth 
Monday, January 16, 2017
GST ADMINISTRATION - A SUGGESTIVE SYSTEM

GST ADMINISTRATION - A SUGGESTIVE SYSTEM

The Union Finance minister, Sh. Arun Jaitely , his team, GST council and all state Governments are to be congratulated for resolving most of the issues in the draft SGST and CGST bills, which have been sent for review by law ministry. The contentious issue of administrative control can also be brought to a mutually acceptable consensus. The following may be considered in this regard : 
1. The GSTN system including its creation, up-dating, up-gradation, maintenance and supervision should be the responsibility of Central Government. This will include entire network, computer nodes, hardware and software to be used at all levels by all stakeholders. This can also be available in different regional languages. The GSTN portal should be so developed so that all stake holders can use the software to meet all filing and reconcillation need and are not required to depend on costly hardware or software or technical support. 
2. The Ground level VAT administration including in respect of CST was always with respective State governments and can continue to be the same way. All existing central Government revenue officials and their team can be transferred to State government roles to be submerged administratively and to supervise the junior levels. The State Government senior officials can also be part of same designation levels as may be equivalent. Excise duty is an important levy and supervision of manufacturing sector as specialised experience will also be with entire team. This could be a system similar to the police department, where IPS officers administratively report to the State government under same supervision from the Home ministry. 
3. The entire team at state level should be functionally responsible to Central as well as to State government. The administrative control can vest with the State. The Central government can have powers of transfer, promotions of all the Central Government revenue officials from one state to another and the GST council  can also define their role and responsibility at various levels. 
4. The entire cost of the manpower at the Central and the State government can be shared in an equitable manner (may be in the ratio of revenue earned). 
5. Administrative Guidelines: The law should clearly define administrative and functional guidelines for officers and employees at various levels. There should be one team and not two teams as per law and rules, guidelines and administrative instructions issued thereunder, as may be amended by GST council from time to time, should ensure: 
  • No visit to tax payer or their premises under any circumstance , except for search duly authorised electronically not at a level below 2nd level of management
  • 100% electronic interface between department and taxpayer- registration, returns, assessment, review, rectifications, refund, rebate, amendments, payments, surrender of registration and grievances handling No inspector or physical inspection of any kind at the premises neither of taxpayer nor to call for physical records at the department. 
  • A Comprehensive GST Audit Report by Chartered Accountant Tax Audit report under Section 44AB of Income Tax Act can be included as two separate portion. This will help comprehensive 360° review. Least additional cost to the taxpayer. Reconciliation of GST returns with the financial statements and comprehensive GST reporting, duly verified from the books of accounts by the auditors.
  • To ensure no Audit is undertaken by GST officials under any circumstances. In complex or deserving cases special Audit by Government appointed CAs can be undertaken, fee to be paid by the Government. 
  • All returns are to be accepted as it is. In sample scrutiny cases (1% or less), all questionnaires are to be sent and responded electronically. Similar to Income tax law, as being implemented.
6. A Central team can be constituted by the advice of GST Council to monitor interstate movement of goods and their proper tracking in GSTN.
7. Regular MIS to all Central and State governments.
8. Full access to GSTN Network and information to Central Government, State government and GST Council for transparency.
9. SGST collection to be managed by state Government and IGST as well as CGST should be the responsibility of central treasury, including compensation and reconcilliation.
10. Compliances, Procedures and reforms to be kept very low initially for ease of doing business and to meet standard of high integrity. Based on experience, new/revised mechanism can be brought in place to curb any misuse. The entire State government GST machinery can be supervised for vigilance, revenue leakage, corruption and harassment by Central Government appointed CBI, Department of Revenue Intelligence, Economic Offence wing of State police and Vigilance Team of State government. The GST council and its secretariat at New Delhi to work in close coordination with Department of Revenue- Central Board of Indirect Taxes, Government of India regularly.


Thursday, December 15, 2016
A WAR AGAINST CORRUPTION AND BLACK MONEY

A WAR AGAINST CORRUPTION AND BLACK MONEY

The Prime Ministers strongest action against corruption and black money by de recognising High Denomination Notes is a historical step. The de monetisation of Rs. 1000 and Rs. 500 Rupee notes on 8th November has brought India on the centre stage of discussion and acclamation worldwide. The Indian economy has seen major impact of this decision and rampant money laundering exercise has been observed by the entire system:

  • Gold and Diamond brisk sale in first 7 days at hefty premium 
  • Heavy import of Gold officially as well as through other channels 
  • Transactions in Real Estate at official price in large numbers at hefty premium
  • Currency Mafia became active exchanging old HDN notes with new currency 
  • A large number of bankers and unprofessional middleman contributed to the Chaos of common man by contributing to the currency Mafia 

The deposit of old currency in bank accounts also picked up substantially and it looks likely that the entire money in circulation will get deposited by 30th December 2016, barring a small percentage to walk in through RBI exchange route in Jan- March 2017. The message from the government is loud and clear that " Na Khaunga Na Khanne Doonga". The real war against the menace of black money got strengthened by the nation wide support to the great initiative. The issue being debated is as to what will be the implication of this move. The following clear indications are coming:


  • A higher tax collection voluntarily from a larger number of new and existing assessees 
  • A reasonably large voluntary disclosure in new scheme of 50% tax and 25% deposit
  • A large additional bank deposit base leaving about 400,000 Crores to 600,000 crores 
  • The M 3 ( Money Velocity ) of 6 to 10 times to create substantial additional resources for the system An expected reduction of interest rates by 300 basis points ( 3%) lowering EMI and interest burden Big push to Housing, Automobiles, Steel, Cement and infrastructure sector 
  • Revival of Non- performing assets ( Bank Loans) with a lower interest burden will ensure sustainability for larger number of borrowers improving potential for debt restructuring, one time settlement and waiver of accumulated high interest burden 
  • GDP growth to marginally slow down in 5 months ending 31st March 2016, followed by a GDP growth rate crossing 10% in 2017-18 
  • Less cash economy initiative will require lesser currency issuance by Government 
  • Significant reduction in public debt and interest rates (Yield to maturity) will reduce burden on the Government and will reduce deficit financing substantially 
  • Significant reduction in Bank Deposit rates , except for senior citizens and special classes 
  • A major reduction in Income Tax rates and upward revision of exemption and taxation slabs
  • The Government can even consider a lower GST middle rate at 4% lower in the announced rate of 12% and 18%. The Excise duty rates and Service tax rates can be immediately cut  pending the GST implementation, which is likely to take some more time in consensus building
  • Mandatory electronic interface between tax assessee and tax officials has already been announced. In case it is implemented in direct and indirect taxes this year, a major blow to hit corruption can be achieved.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 The persuasive approach of Prime Minister has distinguished clearly between the honest and dishonest tax payers. The incentive to hoard cash will also wane away in the course of time. The properties will become affordable even by the honest. Several other sin in the society will get a big hit for example dowry, lavish expenditure on marriages, unnecessary spent and accumulation of jewellery and so on. Even the terrorism and other crimes will reduce with more and more cash less economy.

Can we achieve upliftment of common man, make in India and evolution of India as number one economy will depend on how fast we move along with Prime Minister and take his initiative forward. The complete eradication of black money will depend on determination of the society leaving a better honest economic system to the next generation.


Tuesday, November 15, 2016
LIBERAL NORMS FOR COMMODITY OPTIONS

LIBERAL NORMS FOR COMMODITY OPTIONS

It is welcome that the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) has decided, in principle, to let commodity exchanges introduce trading in options. Such contracts, bought for a price called the premium, give their holders the right to buy or sell a security at a predetermined price. We need both futures and options to better manage supply and demand and attendant commodity prices. Yet, the fact is that a host of rigidities and anomalies constrain and stultify the commodities market here, and keep it functioning below potential. The world over, commodities are recognised as an asset class. Sebi has now given its nod to launch futures contracts in six new items, including diamonds, tea and eggs, bringing the number of such notified items to 91. Yet, futures trading stands curtailed, in terms of who can trade and in what commodities. Futures are banned, for example, in tur and urad dal and rice. Banks and mutual funds cannot trade in commodity derivatives. Regulated warehouses, whose receipts are negotiable instruments, must proliferate. Also, to deepen and widen the market, foreign investors must be allowed in. There's also the need to rationalise trading margins and position limits. Further, there's the need to permit over the-counter contracts (OTC) in commodity derivatives, and also make way for cash settlement of index-like products in the asset class. Besides, we need foolproof transparency when it comes to sharing of information with brokers and traders. The way forward is demutualisation and corporatisation of all recognised commodity associations. A vibrant derivatives market would mean better instruments to manage prices and supplies of both agricultural and other commodities and better distribution of risk across society.
MULTIPLE RATES OF GST FINE FOR SOME SIN GOODS

MULTIPLE RATES OF GST FINE FOR SOME SIN GOODS

The Centre has reportedly proposed four rates - ranging from 6 per cent to 26 per cent - for the goods and services tax (GST), with a cess on the highest tariff for ultra-luxury and demerit goods. This makes sense. The notion that multiple rates are hostile to GST is misplaced. They have functioned in the EU where value added tax (VAT) rates vary among member states, and there is no reason why it will not work in India. Two standard rates of 12 per cent and 18 per cent, presumably worked out after excluding real estate, electricity, alcohol and petroleum products, will cover a majority of taxable goods. A lower slab of 6 per cent for essential goods that do not attract excise duty is welcome, given that exemptions break the GST chain, increase the possibility of evasion and create systemic inefficiencies. A 4 per cent GST on gold is in sync with the recommendations of the Arvind Subramanian panel. It will help wean consumers away from gold and reduce inflationary pressures.

A case for Lower rates
In view of demonitisation, the government can consider further relaxing subjected GST rate by 4% to achieve better compliance and curb black money creation.

The panel had recommended a composite 40 per cent excise duty on non-merit goods. Instead, the Centre has now proposed a 26 per cent rate and a cess component not eligible for input tax credit. This will keep the GST chain unbroken, while discouraging sin consumption and mobilising revenue for the Centre outside the divisible pool. Manufacturers can also claim credit for the taxes paid on demerit goods used to make the final product. However, states are miffed as cesses are excluded from the divisible pool. With a dual GST, states will collect tax on services that account for a lion's share of GDP, on par with the Centre, and also get to tax the value addition in the production of goods. In addition, the Centre has guaranteed full compensation for revenue loss during the transition to GST for five years. So, states must see reason.There is a case for revising the system of the Centre sharing taxes with the states. While income and customs taxes are best collected by the Centre and shared with the states, there is little reason for the Centre to share central GST proceeds with the states, apart from what is required to compensate states for revenue loss.
Saturday, October 15, 2016
MORE REFORM NEEDED IN RETIREMENT SAVINGS

MORE REFORM NEEDED IN RETIREMENT SAVINGS

The pension regulator's move to raise the cap on equity exposure of voluntary subscribers to 75% from 50% through the life cycle fund is welcome. It provides flexibility to a person whose age is 35 years or less to allocate more of her savings to risky equity and reduce that exposure as she moves closer to retirement and her risk-taking ability comes down. Equities in fast growing India offer superior returns along with higher risk. Civil servants are hamstrung as the NPS limits their contribution to a maximum 15% exposure to the stock market, as the investment norms are absurdly linked to the Employees Provident Fund's rules. That must change. The government should take steps forthwith to allow individual civil servants to be treated on par with voluntary savers with regard to choice of asset class and fund manager. The government should also swiftly resolve the legal and operational hurdles to let workers switch to the NPS rather than save with the Employees Provident Fund, if they choose to. This will increase the enrolment to the NPS and substantially increase the pool of funds to be managed by the NPS that has the institutional framework to generate superior returns. More volumes will also bring stability to the system. Locking all savers into exposure to equity regardless of their age profile is a major shortcoming of the EPF and constitutes one more reason for migration to the NPS. Workers will choose to migrate to the NPS only when there is tax parity between the EPFO and the NPS. The EPFO is tax exempt at the three stages of contribution, accumulation and withdrawal whereas NPS is taxed at the time of withdrawal. The government should bring parity to the tax treatment of both retirement saving schemes. 
MILES TO GO BEFORE TRUE COMPETITIVENESS

MILES TO GO BEFORE TRUE COMPETITIVENESS

It is notable that, in the World Economic Forum’s Global Competitiveness Index for 2016-17, India is ranked a credible 39th, and has risen 16 places, the highest rise among all economies. It is commendable that India’s competitiveness seems to have improved across the board, and in particular when it comes to goods market efficiency, business sophistication and innovation. However, the ground reality is that investments, including in the corporate sector, remain sluggish, and the current account deficit has been reduced to the tiny decimal points of national income, meaning that the Indian economy is unable to absorb foreign savings to boost domestic investments.

Note also that outward investments keep rising, suggesting that our corporates are somewhat keener to invest abroad than here. The WEF report adds that while recent reforms have focused on improving public institutions, opening up the economy to foreign investment and increasing transparency in the financial system, a lot remains to be done. Banks remain saddled with bad debt, state power utilities are financially moribund and there is scant growth in formal employment. Besides, when it comes to the Networked Readiness Index, the WEF earlier in July, ranked India a lowly 91st on readiness to transition to a digitised economy and society. We need to reduce infrastructural bottlenecks and improve digital access and skills to step-up productivity and boost inattentiveness economy-wide. In the domain of policy, there’s the pressing need to improve the ease of doing business across sectors and jurisdictions. And in tandem, we need transparency in electoral funding across political parties to purposefully stem corruption and the generation of unaccounted black money. It would rev up our competitiveness.
Monday, September 19, 2016
INCOME DECLARATION SCHEME   - Fifth set of FAQs

INCOME DECLARATION SCHEME - Fifth set of FAQs

The Finance Ministry has come out with the fifth set of frequently asked questions providing clarifications for the Income Declaration Scheme.

  • The FAQs provide clarification that fictitious liabilities in an audited balance-sheet can be disclosed under the scheme without linking it to the investment in any specific asset.
  • Further, income declared under the scheme for an earlier assessment year can be taken into account to explain related transactions.
Comment

As a result of FAQ no. 1 & 2 of the Circular dated 18th August, 2016 issued by CBDT, it is clear that it is not mandatory under the IDS 2016, to declare assets and the assessee can choose to declare the undisclosed income in any preceding assessment years. Section 183(1) of the Finance act, 2016 permit declaration of undisclosed income. Section 183(2) is only optional and applies to cases "where the income chargeable to tax is declared in the form of investment in any asset, the FMV of such asset as on the date on commencement of this scheme shall be deemed to be undisclosed income for the purpose of subsection (1)" of Section 183. Accordingly it is the option of assessee to declare undisclosed income in the form of assets or income. It may be appropriate to interpret that once income is declared, the Income so declared can be used to explain acquisition of assets, write back of fictitious liability, or to explain source of certain transactions which are being or may be questioned during assessment proceedings in terms of Section 142/143, Section 148 or Section 153A/153C. Accordingly, once the income is so declared in any preceding AY, the proceedings under Section 142/143, Section 148 or Section 153A/153C, the assessee can explain the source of acquisition or basis of certain transactions, on the basis of such income not disclosed under IDS.
  • Adverse action will not be taken against the declarant by the Financial Intelligence Unit solely on the basis of cash deposits made in banks consequent to declarations made under the scheme.
  • Finally, the period of holding of assets declared under the scheme will be taken on the basis of actual date of acquisition of the asset and not June 1, 2016, as was clarified earlier.
  • Immovable property  The Finance Ministry has also clarified that under the scheme, whenever an immovable property is evidenced by a registered deed, the declarant will have the option to mention the fair market value of such property by applying the cost inflation index to the stamp duty value of the property.
Cash Payment allowed
  • Cash payment of taxes or income disclosed allowed to be deposited in bank.
  • There won't be any scrutiny of such cash payment of taxes or deposit of income.
  • Valuation by registered valuers won't be questioned.
Capital Gains
  • Entire holding period of asset to be considered to decide capital gains liability.
  • Market value as on June 1, 2016 to be taxed.
  • This value to be considered cost price when property sold.
  • Indexation benefit only from April 1, 2016.
Bogus Cases
  • In the case of bogus donations, entire weighted 
    donations to be taxed.
  • Fictitious loans, creditors, advances received, shares capital can be disclosed as income of any preceding AY and these liabilities can be written back as reserves.
Tuesday, August 16, 2016
GST - INDIA ON THE MOVE

GST - INDIA ON THE MOVE


The government of India has been able to make substantial progress in one of the historical reforms, while passing constitutional Amendment Bill by Parliament, practically unanimously to bring in a common indirect tax " Goods and Services Tax". The federal Union of India got further strengthened by "One India one market" gaining significant strength. The following benefits are envisaged:
    • Sub merger of most of the indirect taxes at State level and at Centre into one single Tax - GST.
    • Transparency in business processes.
    • No cascading effect of taxes, as credit for tax paid by the vendor supplying the goods will be fully adjustable in tax payable on sales invoices by the seller, at the time of sales- Seamless credit in successive transactions.
    • Destination or consumption based taxation i.e. the tax will be borne by ultimate consumer in the state of consuming goods and service.
    • Exports to be more competitive.
    • Movement of goods within India to ease significantly.
    • India to emerge as one single market, expanding growth potential.
The benefits could be many and all of them cannot be enlisted. The Modi Government biggest success is to achieve unanimity in Rajya Sabha, which will pave way for smoother parliament democracy and better political atmosphere, being most important for peace and progress. BJP, PM Narendra Modi, Shri Arun Jaitely, Shri Amit Shah all are to be congratulated. At the same time congress, and entire UPA as well as communist party all are to be given adequate credit for their support.

Tasks ahead

The constitution amendment bill is now required to be passed by majority of the Sates in their State legislature. Thereafter only the constitutional amendment will become valid on receiving President assent.

The real challenge will be to pass the detailed law for:
  • Central GST
  • State GST
  • Interstate (Integrated) GST

The actual drafts of these laws are to be fine- tuned before presenting the same before the parliament and all state legislatures. The bills will be required to be debated thread bare to examine all practical issues and to find workable solutions acceptable to all stakeholders. This looks simple but complexities will come as various stakeholders examine actual impact on them. In all likelihood bills will be referred to select committee of parliament as well as of State level select committees of the state legislature, where all stakeholders will be heard.

It is important to not to pass the bill into final law in a hurry. Even the working Rules and Returns to form part of the law will be a still larger challenge. It will also be crucial to provide at least 6 months to 12 months for detailed examination and preparation to the users of law after the Act and Rules are in place, before they are notified. Any compromise on this aspect will severely impact businesses 
adversely. The law need to be disseminated, understood and all processes will need finalization by each stakeholder. Even the accounting and ERP software will have to be substantially upgraded and modified to change entirely in accordance with law. A reasonable target of final notified date could be 1st April 2019.

The following major decisions will also be important at the end of the Government:
  • Information technology backbone, system and processes.
  • Department and officials to administer manufacturers, traders, service providers- division between states and central Government. Even the Government machinery will need training and understanding of law clearly.
  • Decision on
  • Tax free products and services,
  • "NIL" Tax products and services,
  • Low rate tax products and services,
  • Maximum ceiling tax rate - Goods or Services
  • Process to ensure that no large refunds or unadjusted credit remains with dealers e.g. with exporters, adversely impacting trade or commerce.
  • Collection methodology from importers.
  • Special tax zone like Jammu & Kashmir, Uttaranchal, Assam and Eastern states, Himachal -existing continuing exemptions on "NIL" tax regime & other migration issue.
  • Incentive mechanism for segments to be promoted.
  • Tax on food items, housing, jewellery, education, health, legal services, regulatory and government services needs careful handling.
  • Off books transactions and parallel economy will be a larger challenge.
  • Tax rate on services has to be much lower than Goods to ensure growth of service sector, existing credits, procedures, processes, returns, registration, exemption threshold and so on.
We, Chartered Accountants will have a major role in GST's successful implementation and its effectiveness, efficiency and smooth functioning. We are ready to take on the major task ahead and support the Government as well as businesses in implementation, with minimum pain and teething troubles in initial 2 years & thereafter.

Friday, July 15, 2016
PRIVATIZATION OF EDUCATION  SECTOR - THERE IS A NEED?

PRIVATIZATION OF EDUCATION SECTOR - THERE IS A NEED?

The society need to debate as to whether government needs to permit private companies to undertake education at school level and for higher education. The current compulsion of a society or a trust can be done away with and an option can be provided for profit motive education sector. The private sector can be mandated to provide 33% seats for weaker section of the society. No tax concession and land at market rates. Even world Class University can be permitted in private sector. This can be coupled with an Education regulator and national level cenralised examination Boards for all major qualifications.

The government also needs to heavily invest in effective and efficient education in a big way to ensure skill building for all sections of the society, in a competitive manner.
INCOME DECLARATION SCHEME - A time to come clean

INCOME DECLARATION SCHEME - A time to come clean

Income Declaration Scheme - A Time to Come Clean
The IDS scheme announced by the government is open till 30th September, 2016. It is an important opportunity and the government has committed to not to seek any details or source of money earned and assets created once disclosed in terms of the scheme.

No details about the income or tax so paid will be disclosed to any other person and not even to the tax department officials. The effective tax rate can even be lower as compared to normal maximum marginal rate.No details about the income or tax so paid will be disclosed to any other person and not even to the tax department officials.

The government need to consider removing all apprehensions in the mind of persons coming out clean and may permit:-
  • Extending the scheme to all cases under scrutiny (sec. 142 and sec. 143) or under reassessment (sec. 148) and even raid cases (Section 153A and 153C), where evidence of such income has not been clearly established,in case of the declarant during the proceedings.
  • Complete immunity from all central laws including service tax, excise, customs, SEBI, company law etc.
  • Cases under investigation/survey at any stage including long term capital gain cases, sec. 68 allegations, cases under settlement, under appeal or under litigation in any manner.
  • To continue to treat the asset declared in the scheme a long term asset as long term and not to restart the period from 1st June, 2016
  • The assessee can have clear option to declare cash or assets and in case cash income is declared, usage of such cash later for acquisition of any property duly registered thereafter can be justified.
  • The assessee not able to decide exact period of earning need not disclose the period.
  • The Benami properties can be allowed to be sold or transferred to declarant.
  • The valuation reports from approved valuers will not be questioned later can be reaffirmed. The valuation can be at below "circle rate" has already been permitted.
  • Creditors and loans in the books can also be declared under the scheme.
  • The assessee having a cash flow issue may be permitted to pay in quarterly installments over 30 months, with no interest for payment as per committed time frame.
There is a demand from Non-Residents to rephrase the word "penalty of 7.5%" to "additional tax" or "cess".

The government may also extend Dispute Resolution Scheme to all kind of disputes pending at any stage of litigation or settlement or arbitration and not to limit the same to matter pending as on a particular date or those pending before CIT Appeals. Even penalty/prosecution cases of TDS or under any other section or stage can be given an option to be covered by this scheme. No further penalty or prosecution.

It is important to bring black money into main stream to benefit the businesses, manufacturing, economy and the society. The employment generation, infrastructure and development can be funded from the proceeds.

The Government needs to concentrate on substantial reduction of revenue expenditure so that overall tax burden in future can be lower than even 25% proposed by Finance Minister. Dividend distribution tax and high tax on salary class also need to be addressed for participation of all in nation building. GST will need careful handling for smooth implementation.
Wednesday, June 15, 2016
EASE OF DOING BUSINESS - India need to move fast forward

EASE OF DOING BUSINESS - India need to move fast forward

The Modi Government is committed to significantly improve the working environment for businesses to foster growth, employment, eradication of poverty paving way for significant improvement in education; health and housing for all Indians by bringing ease of doing business.

The initiatives taken by the Government have already created a positive atmosphere and mindset. The nation is committed for Make in India and to aggressively implement growth strategy for India. A big push in the direction of removing regulatory and bureaucratic hurdles including approvals, inspections, filing, licenses, reviews, returns, detailed compliance's and procedures is very necessary.

The government action on withdrawal of old unrequired legislation need to be supplemented by rationalization of all legislation, which are impacting growth of business significantly. Government has made several approvals faster and easy besides introducing electronic governance systems. However, all major hurdles in growth are still hovering on the head of trade, business and commerce. To take few examples:

  • Company Law- full of compliance's, forms, filings, restrictions, limitations, procedures and regulatory requirements even for small company, One person Company or private companies. Most of the restrictions are unnecessary for better efficient and effective corporate Governance.
  • SEBI has introduced so many Regulations, disclosures, Codes and advisories which are not in the interest of sustained growth of capital market. There are inadequate initiatives to channelize risk capital to businesses. Investors' confidence is still very low. SEBI's disclosure based systems have failed to bring real monitoring on diversion of funds, manipulations of markets, poor corporate governance and have resulted in withdrawal of faith of general investor in the capital market. The midsize or even large size company (barring few very exceptionally top companies) are not inclined to raise resources as a public limited listed company due to serious concern on hurdles, cost of issue, compliance's and prosecutions even on technical matters.
  • VAT - With no reliance on businesses, the entire purchase and sales transactions (100%) need to be reported and filed. All inter- state movements of goods are also mandated for advance individual filings. Even small and mid-size traders need very detailed compliance's.
  • Taxation - In spite of deep doze of simplification recently, the transfer pricing, ICDS, TDS, scrutiny, survey, raids, GAAR, POEM, MAT, internationally highest rate of taxes (including dividend tax), corruption are all major challenges,
  • Industrial Laws - the age old labour laws having over doze of minimum wages but hardly protect the welfare of labour. The MNC companies in India are exploiting even white collar employees with no observation of timings, hire and fire. The contract labour is no body's baby. Provident fund law need to be rational and ESI is not meeting any proper objective.
  • Real Estate - the sector is full of licenses, CLUs, approvals, clearances, massive corruption in regulatory department. The in completed projects are waiting for government support to ensure delivery and meet housing needs. The sector need low cost funds in addition to strict monitoring on diversion and misuse of funds.

We can keep on writing, but the list is endless. The government is very active at political levels. However the mind-set and approach of the bureaucratic administration and those who are at different levels of government is still full of controls, apprehensions and procedures. The judiciary at lower and middle order, need significant beefing up.

All Indians need to actively support our Bharat Mata with commitment, positive mind set and pragmatic approach for coming out of the hurdles.
AUDIT - ONLY BY AUDITORS

AUDIT - ONLY BY AUDITORS

The Delhi high court, in a leading judgement delivered on 3rd June, 2016, has declared service tax audit being conducted by Central Excise and Service tax department as ultra virus, in the matter of Mega Cabs Vs UOI. The matter was argued by Mr. J.K. Mittal, FCA as advocate of the petitioner.

The court held that audit is a specialized function and cannot be delegated to service tax department or Excise department. It has been a general practice of the service tax department to conduct Audit of Service tax assesses for the last 5 years by deputing own officers of the rank of inspectors and Superintendents. Service tax department also seeks voluminous details and seek information in self- specified formats/ annexures. Now this judgement made it clear that the officers of the department have no power to conduct Audit at all. The honorable High Court has also held that the CAG officers have no power to conduct audit of assessee's records.

In our humble submission, audit is a specialized function and the profession of Chartered accountants is rightly trained and experienced for audit. Tax Audit under section 44AB of the Income Tax Act, has immensely benefited Govt. of India, trade and industry. Tax Audit has brought in financial discipline and has reduced the need for detailed scrutiny and significantly improved voluntary compliance's. Also under Sec. 142(2A) of the Income Tax Act, whenever specialized, complex or magnanimous issues are required to be examined in the interest of revenue, the Income Tax Department relies upon the services of the “accountant” (read “chartered accountant as per sec. 288). This is being done for almost 40 years now.

CBEC may kindly consider that detailed scope, coverage and reporting requirements can be brought in for Auditors appointed by assessee, to ensure deeper compliance and reporting. The purpose of the department will be adequately served and excise-service tax assesses will also get professional guidance and support.
Monday, May 16, 2016
Education Sector: Regulation and Development Need for a strategy

Education Sector: Regulation and Development Need for a strategy

The Indian Education has developed leaps and bounds over last 2 decades without any major plan and Govt. policy guiding Regulation and Development. Education is a state subject even then the Central Government need to play an important role in providing affordable high quality education to all sections of society. The following issues and challenges are required to be addressed by State Government, Central Government and very importantly by the education sector itself.


  • Development and implementation of high standard education focused on capability development - CBSE and NCERT kind Institutions are needed not only for School education but also for University educations, Professional qualifications and Vocational.There is a need of the country for
  • Standard and Uniform level of course curriculum, delivery quality
  • National level common examination at all levels, to ensure National and International recognition, acceptability and mobility 
  • To consider permitting profit motive educational institutions without any concession in land prices and full taxation on their income and services. This will off course be subjected to regulation on quality, delivery, examination and reasonable profit margins. 
  • The charitable not for profit education societies enjoying concessional land and tax advantages need to be financially disciplined with a mandate of reasonable fee levels, engagement of high quality faculty by ensuring regulated minimum level of salary and perks through proper banking channels and permitting some profit margin to fund growth. No misuse or diversion can go on.
  • The admission process, criteria of local preferences, donations and capitation fee, reservation of corporate seats based on large financial considerations, charging and levying non transparent fees, charges and contributions are some areas of major challenges.
  • Minority educational institutions may also opt for main stream modern education and financial aid and support of Government with committed financial discipline, along with a freedom to preserve their specialties, values, culture and religious education.
  • The Government and Government aided educational institutions need a big focus on improving their infrastructure, delivery mechanism, quality of education and overall standards to attract all sections and classes of the society on one platform - paving way for major opportunities even for weaker and middle income group. Massive expansion and major financial allocation for such facilities is needed.
  • To examine based on detailed research, the impact and challenges faced by weaker section students being educated in high cost private schools based on mandatory reservation.
  • The IIT, IIM and other similar high level institutions - reasonable subsidized high quality education need to come with a commitment towards the country. India is training a majority of them at the cost of society and they join costly jobs internationally.
  • The engineering, Medical, MBA and similar private institutions and Universities need a deep high quality regulations and developmental support
  • Indian education at school level and also at higher level need to also concentrate on Indian Value System, culture, ethics, integrity, history and leadership traits. Team spirit and development of respect and tolerance for others' views and priorities is a major challenge.
Transparency in Financial Management and Education quality, Content and Delivery mechanism need Long term vision, Strategy, firm Commitment, Discipline and deep rooted hard work at all levels duly supported by Regulatory independent review and Developmental support.
   
Modi Government speeding up reforms CAs expectations in waiting

Modi Government speeding up reforms CAs expectations in waiting

NARENDRA Ji Modi Government needs to be congratulated on speeding up the reform process by:

  • UDAY Scheme providing Rs. 99000 crores to State Electricity Boards
  • Launching open transparent electricity purchase portal - rates becoming transparent at Rs. 2.50 to Rs. 3.00 per unit 
  • Bringing down cost of Solar power to Rs. 5.50 per unit
  • Coal supply turning in surplus from decades of shortage
  • All power projects under construction - now being implemented in full swing
  • Railways implementing massive investment for modernization efficiently and effectively
  • Real Estate Regulations Act passed for bringing transparency and fair treatment to consumer
  • Transparent electronic market launched for Agriculture produce
  • Roads projects construction revived and now in full swing in almost 95% cases with large number of new projects
  • Special simplification of Income Tax laws and new schemes
  • Electronic Assessment - no personal visits
  • Voluntary disclosure of Income scheme
  • Regular income declaration freedom
  • Professionals' special tax scheme
  • Kar Vivad Samadhan Scheme - clear road map
  • 10% tax on Research and development in India  
  • Lowering corporate tax rate to 25%
  • Large number of procedural simplifications
  • Positive approach and respect for tax payer
  • Survey, Searches and Raids to be an exception
  • Mandatory ISI mark and minimum National standards for large number of consumer goods, barring import of sub standard Chinese goods and many more.....
  • The expectations are mounting in different areas. The Chartered Accountants community commits their support to transparency, integrity and ethical approach and completely non corrupt Governance. We await :
  • Rationalisation of the Companies Act, 2013
  • Independent appointment of Statutory and Internal Auditors for Banks, Insurance, Pension funds, Mutual funds and all public interest institutions.
  • Fair role of CAs in ensuring financial discipline
  • To eradicate tendering of CAs' professional services. Government need to appoint best persons at pre-determined fee for a top quality efficient and effective reporting. Lawyers, CAs, Doctors cannot be selected on L1 (Lowest quote) basis.  
Friday, April 15, 2016
Non Performing Assets in Banking Sector - Impacting Economic Growth Need for credit monitoring mechanism

Non Performing Assets in Banking Sector - Impacting Economic Growth Need for credit monitoring mechanism

The cases and overall quantum of Non Performing Assets in Banking Sector have reached alarming levels. RBI has specially brought out a list of 150 extra large borrowers having weak financial health. The size of borrowings by certain borrowers has grown geometrically impacting debt-equity ratio, large and risky financial leverage and risk to financial market system. In view of large NPA, the Banking system has become averse to further lending, thereby negatively impacting Make in India, New projects, expansion, working capital and growth and growth momentum of economy.

An In-depth research into the issues involved clearly bring out following major issues:-


  • The Assessment of credit need, strength and sources of promoters, viability of the project, estimated time for completion, risk of contingency, regulatory and policy risk is inefficient and ineffective. The systems are not commensurate to the need and there is significant lack of appropriate skills within the banking sector. 
  • The professional integrity, ethics, professional business friendly approach need commitment and strengthening. 
  • The terms of sanction including pre-disbursal and post disbursal conditions are not complied with in majority of the cases, including in respect of 
  • Promoter's contribution
  • End use of funds
  • Prior approval before further borrowing
  • Major capital expenditure commitment by borrower and the group companies.
  • Share transfer/pledge by promoters including borrowing against the same and its end use
  •  Investment in associates, subsidiaries etc.
  • Extending advances not in the ordinary course of business
No effective action is taken by the banks in case of non compliance and in most of large cases, a relaxed view is taken
  • Monitoring of audited accounts and quarterly results of the borrowers, their subsidiary companies, associates and other group companies and related parties is seriously weak
  • The drawing power allowed to borrowers on the basis of inventory and debtors is not supported by credible and verified information.
  • The Issues highlighted in the borrower's Audit Report and Notes to Accounts are ignored.
  • Diversion of funds or improper end use is not monitored by detailed scrutiny of Annual/Quarterly financial statements. The break up schedules and actual facts behind the published figures are ignored.
  • Related party transactions, overdue debtors, non moving stocks, advances not relating to business, unapproved investments are all ignored.
  • Increase in Current liabilities, Secured loans of borrower from third parties, Borrowings from other banks, NBFCs, Commercial paper, Debentures and Deposits are not taken into consideration while monitoring credit. 
  • The bank's Board of Directors, Top management and Middle management have a big dearth of knowledge and skill to analyse borrower's financials, notes and their qualification in their Audit Reports. There is hardly any system to monitor financial statements and actual physical operations of even very large borrowers on an ongoing basis or even during disbursements.
  • Early warning signals are not captured for necessary action.
  • The appointment of auditors has been left in the hands of top management of banks, adversely impacting quality and depth of audit 
  • Even branch audits appointments has been restricted to 20% large branches and appointments are made very late towards end of March, while expecting and insisting reports in 7 to 10 days, leaving hardly any time for detailed review. The appointment is being made by management and not by independent persons.
  • Inadequate action is taken on audit reports by bank auditors including account wise comments in long form Audit Reports. Even there is no focus on credit monitoring through a specialized Audit keeping in view that internal credit monitoring is very weak.
  • The concurrent audit's scope coverage and reporting requirements are mis-directed to routine verification's
  • There is a need for major overhaul in the Indian Banking system including:
  •  Strengthening of the Board of directors, top management and key positions by capable and rightly qualified persons. Employment of qualified Chartered Accountants in larger numbers will significantly help.
  • Borrowers have to have the fear of judiciary and legal action including loosing of management and control of the entity itself
  • The time spent on judiciary process needs to be curtailed drastically. 
  •  Credit Monitoring within the bank and from outside experts of high quality need to be institutionalized. There is a need to appoint 2 independent professional Directors as selected by Banks to monitor day to day operations and fund management
  • A regular Bank Information System is to be put in place so that periodical updates of borrower, Group companies, subsidiaries, associates, related party transactions and specific areas and nature of transactions is duly reported to the bank as certified by an Independent firm of Chartered Accountants.
  • The Bank Auditors need to bring out all cases of misfeasance, diversion of funds, potential sickness and lack of financial discipline among borrowers, independently in an efficient and excellent manner
  • The appointment of auditors needs to be undertaken independent of Bank's management.
  • RBI has been one of the most effective regulator and banking supervision and guidance has to be revamped significantly by RBI. Even RBI annual inspection report should be an open public document at least for all levels of bank management and all Auditors and consultants.
  • A comparative study of status of NPA in Private sector banks & Public sector bank need to be done to understand the real reasons of high NPA in public sector banks
  • The role of politicians, ministry of finance and administrators in the working of public sector banks.
  • Industry specific factors shall be considered before declaration of an account as NPA. Every industry has its distinctive features. Let the NPA norms be formulated and modified accordingly. 
Tuesday, March 15, 2016
Large Bank Borrowers - Are they willful defaulters?

Large Bank Borrowers - Are they willful defaulters?

The RBI advisory for mandatory provisions of Non-Performing Assets and inclusion of most of the
top borrowers in the list of 150 groups covering lakhs of crores of borrowings has brought to surface
a very major issue. The weaknesses in the health of the borrowers noticed by the Reserve Bank on the basis of delay in payment of interest or repayment of installments or diversion in financial parameters (debt-equity norms, liquid ratio, delay in project implementation, non achievement of targeted turnovers, non adherence to restructuring terms and similar other parameters) or other financial indicators indicating weaknesses in the health of borrowers and resultant mandatory treatments of the amount borrowed as non performing assets has broken all previous records. The entire banking system in the country is under threat of a major shakeup. It is therefore very important to examine
as to whether every default makes a borrower a "defaulter" and all the more a "willful defaulter". It is important to undertake a detailed examination, including a forensic audit of all major and material defaulters, to identify as to whether the poor health of a particular borrower or a group is result of economic slowdown, policy hiccups or other matters beyond the control of borrowing entity and the promoters. Additionally, the following important aspects are required to be considered to identify as to whether a borrower is a "defaulter" and all the more a "willful defaulter". An overall holistic assessment of the following parameters would be very important:


  • The factual disclosure - Whether all the facts relating to the borrowing entity, the promoter (and the group entities belonging to beneficial owners), the project, capacity, cost of the project, means of finance, suppliers, market study, and other project parameters  have been disclosed in a true and fair manner to the bankers at the time of initial borrowings, additional borrowings (in case of over-run) and expansions or diversification.

  • Diversion of Funds
  • Inclusion of bogus bills/ inflated bills for purchase 
  • of capital assets or operating expenses - Purchases 
  • made from related parties/ parties having skeleton 
  • operations(i.e. the parties used for routing the 
  • transactions) could indicate prima facie lack of due 
  • diligence and lack of fair play. In the process of purchase, 
  • in terms of finance control, due diligence records of the  
  • supplier will be very important to examine.
  • Book entries for creation of capital or false 
  • capitalization and various other financial  
  • engineering to manipulate the correct picture.
Role of the Reserve Bank of India

The RBI needs to strengthen its regulatory framework. The entire responsibility of the current scenario has to be taken by the Reserve Bank. The efficacy of RBI inspections, regulatory guidelines, Statutory Audits, Concurrent Audits, Internal Audits, Inspection audits, Stock Audits and credit monitoring audits have been very severely damaged due to lack of timely initiatives of the RBI to ensure proper monitoring with detailed scope, coverage and reporting requirements of not only in respect of lending banks but also of all major borrowers. The remarks contained in special long form audit reports given by auditors for all major borrowers exceeding 2 crore borrowings, were either not looked at or were not followed up properly at the end of the regulators as well as by the banks. The appointment of auditors by banks management at the Central Statutory Auditor level as well as the branch level and reduction in number of branches being subject to audit at the initiative of Reserve Bank and the then Finance Minister had put a very big nail in the coffin of financial proprietary.

Way Forward

It is very important not only to analyse the reasons of the current situation and to provide a fair deal to the industry as well as to the banking professionals. It is also necessary to put in place necessary regulatory measures to prevent occurrence of ugly situations. Some of the suggestions which may be considered are as follows:

  • Group concept need to be implemented for all appraisals and assessments and the borrowers promoters are required to be mandated to disclose actual performance of the units/companies managed by them (including all close relatives) during last twenty years and cases of defaults, settlements diversions, failures and good performance.
  • The borrowers group need to confirm on affidavit about true and fair disclosure and personal liability of the promoter and his family (close relatives), in case of wrongful disclosures or non-disclosure of any material aspect or diversion of funds, over invoicing, in genuine book entries and so on.
  • The lending bankers need to play a very important role in credit monitoring. The credit monitoring need to be intensified as the exposure per unit or per group goes up based on overall exposure of the banking  system as a whole and not based on exposure on respective banks alone.
  • Multiple banking needs to be replaced by consortium banking. The consortium leader and the participating banker's rights and responsibilities to be defined by clear cut code. The banks need to ensure that basic fundamental principle of financial management is being followed by the borrower as well as the group. NO borrowing outside consortium to be permitted in the group companies also.
  • Effective bank nominees need to be appointed on the board of the borrowers as well as the group entities. Higher the exposure, higher the number of borrowers, nominees on the board of directors.
  • Utilisation of Funds - The current monitoring of utilization of funds is only a force. At best, a certificate is sought from the auditors or the independent lender's engineers. None of this is a serious exercise.
  •  
It is important to appoint independent monitoring agencies and independent auditors to ensure a check on diversion of funds , bogus bills, false book entries and unethical financial engineering.
Tuesday, February 16, 2016
Banking Sector – Under scanner

Banking Sector – Under scanner

The Reserve Bank of India had recently directed to Public Sector Banks as well as Private Sector
Banks to downgrade the asset classification of more than 150 borrower accounts, based upon Asset Quality review, to Non- Performing Assets (NPAs). The exposure of banking sector to such borrower accounts was in the range of Rs 1,50,000 Crores to Rs 2,00,000 Crores. Primarily RBI had recently issued advisory to downgrade specific large 150 identified accounts in following categories to
Non- performing assets:

  • Accounts to be downgraded to NPA categories, with retrospective effect (in some cases going back to F.Y. 2012), although these were classified as Standard accounts till 31st March 2015.
  • Diverges observed in case of existing NPAs
  • Non achievement of DCCO (Date of Commencement of Commercial Operations)
  • CDR-restructured accounts - Non fulfillment of conditions - Additional provision recommended in March 2016 Quarter and thereafter every quarter in FY 2017.

Even beyond the current exercise, there are number of stressed cases, which are in the process of being identified by the Statutory Auditors and RBI inspection teams. The total additional provisioning requirement is estimated to be Rs 40,000 cr till March 2016.The quarterly results for most of the banks have been announced , showing significant losses or steep reduction in profitability, resulting into erosion of the Banks' market capitalization by 10% to 20%. The capital market in general has also been subject to blood bath, with widespread losses across sectors, in the range of about Rs 3 lakh crores. While the government and RBI is active in limiting the damage to the financial market, the entire economic sector and society is deeply concerned about the matter and is deliberating on the following major issues:
  • How such a grave situation has piled up over the years?
  • Why the banks management, Reserve Bank of India and other regulators ignored the matter during last couple of years?
  • Whether such loans have genuinely became bad or there was deliberate diversion of funds, willful defaults or improper or reckless financial management?
  • How such large exposures have suddenly grown leaps and bounds to certain specified groups, without corresponding promoter's contribution and adequate safeguards?
  • Multiple banks are involved in almost all large cases. How and why almost all the bank did not wake up to the call in time?
  • The country need to identify, the real conspiracy as to whether and where crucial resources of the country have been diverted?
  • Who are the real culprits? -whether corruption or gross negligence or poor regulatory supervision at the level of banks as well as at the level of Reserve bank of India?
  • Is there anything fundamentally improper in the management structure of the banks and the latest changing scenario?
  • Even significant variation in valuation for restructuring or transfer of assets from one group to another or within the group via related/unrelated Parties need microscopic preview?
It is important to undertake a detailed inquiry in all cases of Non - Performing Assets' classification where exposure is more than Rs 50 Cr - Rs 100 Cr or more. In certain cases the exposure to single group is thousands of Crores. It is important that willful defaulters are identified and also cases of the regulatory failures, issues of managements' weaknesses and need for a thorough overhaul of the Banking System can be identified and addressed. The inquiry has to be completely and very strictly
confidential so that morale of genuine businessmen and more importantly, the market sentiments do not get affected adversely and backwards.

The scope, coverage and the reporting requirements by the Statutory Auditors as well as Internal Auditors are also required to be strengthened by the council of Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. The Audit has to be deep and thorough at National level as well as at Branch and Regional / Zonal level. The profession need not wait for the Reserve Bank of India or the Government action in the matter and should issue regulatory direction, guideline in respect of scope, coverage and reporting requirements, to be mandatory followed by the banking sector, with full support of Reserve Bank of India, Securities & Exchange Board of India, and the government. It is also important to comprehensively upgrade the competence, credibility, integrity and professional caliber and competence of Bank management.The Reserve Bank has been one of the top most and successful regulators and a Central Bank of the highest order. A positively aggressive approach, with an Indian
mindset would be crucial for acceptability of regulatory and financial control framework.